ksh999000/Claude-Code-Game-Studios
1
0
Fork 0
mirror of https://github.com/Donchitos/Claude-Code-Game-Studios.git synced 2026-06-27 04:51:46 +00:00
Code Issues Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

Add v0.6.0: full skill/agent QA pass, 3 new agents tested, template cleanup

Browse Source 
Skills fixed: sprint-status (stale escalation, threshold), retrospective
(existing file detection, missing data fallback), changelog (misc category,
task-ref count), patch-notes (BLOCKED on missing changelog, tone/template
paths), story-readiness (Phase 0 mode resolution, QL-STORY-READY gate),
art-bible, brainstorm, design-system, ux-design, dev-story, story-done,
create-architecture, create-control-manifest, map-systems, propagate-design-change,
quick-design, prototype, asset-spec.

Agents fixed: all 4 directors (gate verdict token format), engine-programmer,
ui-programmer, tools-programmer, technical-artist (engine version safety),
gameplay-programmer (ADR compliance), godot-gdextension-specialist (ABI warning),
systems-designer (escalation path to creative-director), accessibility-specialist
(model, tools, WCAG criterion format, findings template), live-ops-designer
(escalation paths, battle pass value language), qa-tester (model, test case
format, evidence routing, ambiguous criteria, regression scope).

Specs updated: smoke-check and adopt specs rewritten to match actual skill
behavior. catalog.yaml reset to blank template state. Removed
session-state marketing research file, removed session-state from gitignore.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
Donchitos
2026-04-07 17:28:46 +10:00
parent a73ff759c9
commit 3614e1dbfb
37 changed files with 925 additions and 287 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files

29
CCGS Skill Testing Framework/quality-rubric.md
View File

@@ -32,33 +32,42 @@ auto-advancing stage and must respect the three review modes.
**Skills**: design-review, architecture-review, review-all-gdds
Review skills read documents and produce structured verdicts. They are strictly
read-only and must never trigger director gates themselves.
Review skills read documents and produce structured verdicts. They are primarily
read-only and must not trigger director gates during the analysis phase.
| Metric | PASS criteria |
|---|---|
| **R1 — Read-only enforcement** | `allowed-tools` does not include `Write` or `Edit`; skill never offers to modify the reviewed document |
| **R1 — Read-only enforcement** | Skill does not modify the reviewed document without explicit user approval; any write operations (review logs, index updates) are gated behind "May I write" |
| **R2 — 8-section check** | Skill evaluates all 8 required GDD sections (or equivalent architectural sections) explicitly |
| **R3 — Correct verdict vocabulary** | Verdict is exactly one of: APPROVED / NEEDS REVISION / MAJOR REVISION NEEDED (design) or PASS / CONCERNS / FAIL (architecture) |
| **R4 — No director gates** | Skill does not spawn any director gate regardless of review mode; it IS the review |
| **R4 — No director gates during analysis** | Skill does not spawn director gates during its analysis phases; post-analysis director review (as in architecture-review) is acceptable when the skill's scope and stakes warrant it |
| **R5 — Structured findings** | Output contains a per-section status table or checklist before the final verdict |
> **Exceptions:**
> - `design-review`: Has `Write, Edit` in allowed-tools to support an optional "Revise now" path (all writes gated behind user approval) and to write review logs. R1 is satisfied because the reviewed document is never silently modified.
> - `architecture-review`: Spawns TD-ARCHITECTURE and LP-FEASIBILITY gates after its analysis is complete. This is intentional — architecture review is high-stakes and benefits from director sign-off. R4 is satisfied because the gates run post-analysis, not during it.
---
### `authoring`
**Skills**: design-system, quick-design, architecture-decision, ux-design, ux-review, art-bible, create-architecture
Authoring skills create or update design documents section by section. They must
collaborate before writing and handle both new and existing (retrofit) documents.
Authoring skills create or update design documents collaboratively. Full GDD/UX
authoring skills use a section-by-section cycle; lightweight authoring skills use
a single-draft pattern appropriate to their smaller scope.
| Metric | PASS criteria |
|---|---|
| **A1 — Section-by-section cycle** | Skill authors one section at a time, presenting content for approval before proceeding to the next |
| **A2 — May-I-write per section** | Skill asks "May I write this to [filepath]?" before each section write, not just once at the end |
| **A3 — Retrofit mode** | Skill detects if the target file already exists and offers to update specific sections rather than overwriting the whole document |
| **A1 — Section-by-section cycle** | Full authoring skills (design-system, ux-design, art-bible) author one section at a time, presenting content for approval before proceeding to the next. Lightweight skills (quick-design, architecture-decision, create-architecture) may draft the complete document then ask for approval — single-draft is acceptable for documents under ~4 hours of implementation scope. |
| **A2 — May-I-write per section** | Full authoring skills ask "May I write this to [filepath]?" before each section write. Lightweight skills ask once for the complete document. |
| **A3 — Retrofit mode** | Skill detects if the target file already exists and offers to update specific sections rather than overwriting the whole document. Lightweight skills (quick-design) that always create new files are exempt. |
| **A4 — Director gate at correct tier** | If a director gate is defined for this skill (e.g., CD-GDD-ALIGN, TD-ADR), it runs at the correct mode threshold (full/lean) — NOT in solo |
| **A5 — Skeleton-first** | Skill creates a file skeleton with all section headers before filling content, to preserve progress on session interruption |
| **A5 — Skeleton-first** | Full authoring skills create a file skeleton with all section headers before filling content, to preserve progress on session interruption. Lightweight skills are exempt. |
> **Full authoring skills** (must pass all 5 metrics): `design-system`, `ux-design`, `art-bible`
> **Lightweight authoring skills** (A1, A2, A5 use single-draft pattern; A3 exempt for new-file-only skills): `quick-design`, `architecture-decision`, `create-architecture`
> **Review-mode skill** (evaluated against review metrics): `ux-review`
---